Burnham and Badenoch clash over Milburn's youth welfare reform plan
Summarised from 6 outlets · 8 reports · Updated 18 Nov, 13:32 · Archive
Alan Milburn's report proposes overhauling benefits for young people not in education, employment or training, but the government and opposition differ on its scope and savings.
Alan Milburn's 10-year plan aims to halve the proportion of 16 to 24-year-olds classified as Neet – not in education, employment or training – from about 13 per cent to 5 per cent. The report proposes a shake-up of the benefits system to save £3.6 billion a year, with funding redirected to measures getting young people into jobs or training. A so-called 'youth allowance' could replace both the health element of universal credit and personal independence payment for this age group.
At Prime Minister's Questions, Kemi Badenoch attacked the plan from the opposition benches. She said Mr Burnham was giving young people 'false hope' whilst 'kicking things into the long grass', arguing the plan did not envisage any savings for a decade. She accused him of wanting 'the vibes of welfare reform without actually doing any welfare reform'. Working age welfare currently costs £180 billion a year, she noted, with projections to rise to £220 billion.
Mr Burnham pledged to do 'everything that I can as quickly as possible to get the welfare bill down' but did not commit to reducing costs before Parliament closes in 2029. He complained that Ms Badenoch was taking a 'patronising tone' and that the Tories wanted a 'cuts-only' approach. He said his government would set out a full response to Mr Milburn's review next month.
Confusion has surrounded the plan's impact on young people's incomes. Mr Milburn told Sky News that 'there will be some people who in the short-term will get less'. However, Mr Burnham suggested young people would not lose out 'from a cash point of view', arguing those losing benefits would be able to work instead. Downing Street said the Prime Minister meant that young people would not necessarily be worse off because of employment opportunities.
Mr Burnham said he had asked the Cabinet to reprioritise spending plans for 2027-28 to deliver an initial £500 million investment supporting a youth opportunity service, initially delivering 25,000 quality work placements for 16 and 17-year-olds. The Independent reports that the plan is considered 'staggeringly ambitious' among Westminster insiders, though some warned of timing risks for avoiding an MP rebellion.

How it is being reported
- Kemi and Andy put another nail in the coffin of his consensus politics | John CraceThe Tory leader is hardwired for conflict. It was futile for the PM to demand an end to her patronising tone Well, that didn’t take long. When Andy Burnham first arrived in No 10, he said he was determined to do things differently. He wanted a new, consensual politics where he would work with other parties to put the country back together. Safe to say, that dream is already dead in the water. At least when it comes to his exchanges with Kemi Badenoch at prime minister’s questions. Andy might go through the motions of promising Ed Davey and various backbenchers a veneer of cross-party support…The Guardian · 18 Nov, 17:16
- ‘We can’t wait 10 years’: Burnham wavers on bringing down welfare billAndy Burnham has refused to promise to make welfare savings by 2030, just a day after he said he would do so. Asked by Kemi Badenoch on whether he would deliver welfare savings in the near term following his backing of the Alan Milburn review, he said he would do “everything I can” to push [...]City AM · 18 Nov, 14:06
- Andy Burnham says Tories want to throw young people 'on the scrap heap' in fiery PMQsThe Prime Minister accused Tory leader Kemi Badenoch of adopting a 'cuts only' approach to welfare while the government attempts to deal with the thorny issueThe Mirror · 18 Nov, 13:27
- Milburn report is ‘staggeringly ambitious’ – Burnham now faces a race against timeThe 270-page report demands sweeping welfare reform to get NEETs back to work. For Burnham, the clock is now ticking, say Cleo Watson and Helen MacNamara. Maja Anushka writesThe Independent · 18 Nov, 13:25
- Kemi Badenoch accuses Andy Burnham of ‘vibes-based’ approach to welfare reformAlan Milburn’s review called for a shake-up of the benefits system to save £3.6 billion a year.Evening Standard · 18 Nov, 13:14
- Tories accuse Andy Burnham of creating ‘vibes’ of welfare reform without bringing down benefits billIn a fiery clash at Prime Minister's Questions, Tory leader Kemi Badenoch said plans to reduce welfare payments for some young people announced this week did not go far enoughEvening Standard · 18 Nov, 13:10
- 'He isn't finding any savings for 10 years!' Kemi Badenoch roasts Burnham over NEETs plan as she brands Labour 'the welfare party'Kemi Badenoch accused Andy Burnham of heading the 'welfare party' as she pointed out the Milburn plan did not envisage any savings for a decade.Daily Mail · 18 Nov, 12:23
- Andy Burnham sparks confusion over Milburn plan for benefits curbs as he says NEETs won't lose out 'from a cash point of view'Andy Burnham argued that the Milburn plan could be implemented without anyone 'losing out from a cash point of view'.Daily Mail · 18 Nov, 09:12
In this story: Andy Burnham · Alan Milburn · Kemi Badenoch · Pat McFadden · James Purnell · United Kingdom
This summary was written by AI from the headlines and standfirsts above, and states as fact only what at least two outlets report. How we use AI · Report a problem · Corrections log
Comments (0)