New guidance introduced after teenager's cancer was missed
Summarised from 2 outlets · 3 reports · Updated 20 Nov, 06:32 · Archive
Scotland has introduced new national guidance for diagnosing cancer in young people, named after Isla Sneddon, who died aged 17 after her cancer referral was downgraded.
Isla Sneddon from Airdrie first presented with a breast lump aged 15 but her symptoms were repeatedly dismissed as anxiety and hormones. When a cancer referral was eventually made, the breast clinic downgraded it from urgent to routine because of her young age. The cancer went undetected for more than two years before Isla was diagnosed with a rare sarcoma that had spread to her heart, lungs and lymph nodes. She died in March 2025 aged 17, just six months after diagnosis.
Her parents Mark and Michelle launched a campaign to ensure paediatric cancer referrals receive the same urgency as those for adults. The Scottish Government has now introduced Isla's Principles, national guidance developed in their daughter's name. The acronym ISLA sets out four key actions: intuition, asking doctors to use professional judgement; sharing information between GPs, hospitals and specialists; agreeing a plan with the young person and their family; and listening to persistent concerns. The guidance warns that young people may appear well even when presenting with concerning symptoms, and urges clinicians to take a fresh look when symptoms persist, evolve or recur.
Speaking in the Scottish Parliament, Health Secretary Angela Constance stopped short of acknowledging failings in Isla's case, instead stating that the Scottish Government recognised the importance of accountability and had made Isla's Principles 'a very important commitment'. Isla's parents have criticised the lack of accountability for what happened to their daughter. Mark Sneddon said: 'It's terrible that our tragedy has to be the catalyst for change.'

How it is being reported
- 'Nobody knew Isla was dying, now she might change that for others'Isla Sneddon died age 17 and a new protocol has been launched in her name to protect other young people.BBC Glasgow And West · 20 Nov, 06:01
- ‘Cancer delays took our daughter – why did it take her death to bring change?’GPs dismissed Isla Sneddon's painful breast lump as hormones and her cancer referral was downgraded from urgent. In her memory, her parents have campaigned for change.The Herald · 20 Nov, 00:01
- Health Secretary stops short of acknowledging failings in Isla Sneddon cancer caseScotland introduces Isla’s Principles after teenager Isla Sneddon’s cancer referral was downgraded, but Angela Constance stops short of admitting failings.The Herald · 20 Nov, 00:01
In this story: Isla Sneddon · Mark Sneddon · Michelle Sneddon · Angela Constance · Scotland · Airdrie · Scottish Government
This summary was written by AI from the headlines and standfirsts above, and states as fact only what at least two outlets report. How we use AI · Report a problem · Corrections log
Comments (0)