Phoenix prosecutor defends sending cold case back to police
Summarised from 2 outlets · Updated 18 Nov, 23:32 · Archive
Maricopa County Attorney Rachel Mitchell defended sending a 2013 Phoenix security guard murder case back to police for further investigation.
Nearly 13 years after Phoenix security guard Jeffrey Bellemare was shot and killed at work, police arrested a suspect in his murder earlier this month. However, the Maricopa County Attorney's Office sent the case against 43-year-old Joe Gerardo back to police for further investigation rather than filing charges.
At a news conference on Wednesday, Maricopa County Attorney Rachel Mitchell defended the decision. She said she needs a 'strong, viable case' before filing charges and cannot proceed based on hoped-for evidence. 'I get one chance to get it right,' she said. Mitchell explained that cold cases present specific challenges including determining witness availability, whether evidence remains intact and whether the chain of custody has been maintained.
Mitchell also addressed her office's decision to seek the death penalty against Randal Basilio Santillan, 27, accused of stabbing 18-year-old Phoenix woman Yessenia Norman to death. Norman was killed by someone she had met online. Mitchell said her office reviews all cases with the same standard: 'whether it is provable.'

How it is being reported
- Cold case sent back, death penalty sought: Rachel Mitchell defends decisionsNearly 13 years after a Phoenix security guard was killed, Rachel Mitchell explains why prosecutors sent the murder case back to police.KOLD · 18 Nov, 22:56
- Cold case sent back, death penalty sought: Rachel Mitchell defends decisionsNearly 13 years after a Phoenix security guard was killed, Rachel Mitchell explains why prosecutors sent the murder case back to police.Azfamily · 18 Nov, 22:56
In this story: Rachel Mitchell · Jeffrey Bellemare · Joe Gerardo · Phoenix · Maricopa County · Randal Basilio Santillan · Yessenia Norman
This summary was written by AI from the headlines and standfirsts above, and states as fact only what at least two outlets report. How we use AI · Report a problem · Corrections log
Comments (0)