Court case dropped against nurse fined while trapped in lift
Summarised from 2 outlets · Updated 12 Nov, 12:32 · Archive
Court action has been dropped against a Dudley nurse fined for parking while trapped in a lift during a patient visit.
A Dudley community nurse has had court action dropped against her after receiving a parking fine incurred while she was trapped in a lift. Lisa Smith parked in a permit-only bay in Perry Barr Village, Birmingham, in November 2025 while visiting a sick child. Medical staff are allowed to park in such bays for 30 minutes, but Smith became stuck in a lift for more than 20 minutes before being freed by a resident, causing her to exceed her permitted parking time.
Civil Enforcement Ltd issued Smith a penalty charge notice of £266 and pursued court action to recover the sum. However, the court has now discontinued the case. Smith said she provided evidence from the start explaining her circumstances and believes she is owed an apology and an explanation for why the company pursued the matter so vigorously.
Smith's local MP, Sonia Kumar, intervened by writing to Civil Enforcement Ltd asking for the proceedings to be halted. Kumar said Smith was carrying out essential NHS work caring for a vulnerable child. Smith was initially unaware of the parking charge because she was driving an NHS pool car and was later off work due to illness.

How it is being reported
- MP welcomes ‘common sense’ dropping of court threat against nurse over parking chargeNurse Lisa Smith stayed longer than her free parking permit allowed because she got stuck in a lift on her way to treat a childExpress & Star · 12 Nov, 12:12
- Court action against nurse trapped in lift droppedLisa Smith was pursued over a fine given while she was trapped in a lift when visiting a sick child.BBC Birmingham And Black Country · 12 Nov, 06:09
In this story: Lisa Smith · Sonia Kumar · Civil Enforcement Ltd · Dudley · Birmingham · Perry Barr Village
This summary was written by AI from the headlines and standfirsts above, and states as fact only what at least two outlets report. How we use AI · Report a problem · Corrections log
Comments (0)