Teacher loses appeal on abuse ruling despite judge's Facebook posts
Summarised from 2 outlets · Updated 16 Nov, 20:31 · Archive
A retired teacher has lost an appeal against a $1.6 million child sexual abuse compensation ruling.
Stephen Noga, a retired teacher, has lost his appeal against a $1.6 million compensation ruling in a civil case brought by a female former student who alleged sexual abuse in the 1980s. Justice Stephen Estcourt awarded the compensation in April, finding on the balance of probabilities that Noga raped the woman at a hotel in 1981 when she was 16 and his student.
Noga appealed on grounds of apprehended bias, citing Facebook posts made by Justice Estcourt around the time of the trial. Posts from an account under the judge's name included links to a Women's Agenda story titled "The attempt to punish Grace Tame tells us everything about how we treat women who speak up" and a "haunting and emotional poem about sexual assault" by American singer Halsey. Grace Tame was the 2021 Australian of the Year and a child sexual abuse survivor who has advocated for victims.
Tasmania's Full Court of Appeal on Monday found that a reasonable observer would have reason to believe the posts might relate to the case because of their timing. The court concluded that "a reasonable person would develop an apprehension Justice Estcourt might 'consciously or unconsciously, err in favour of the respondent and against the appellant'." Despite these findings about potential bias, Noga's appeal was unsuccessful.

How it is being reported
- Court makes call on judge's contentious Facebook postsA court has made a ruling on claims by an ex-teacher, who appealed against paying a child sexual abuse survivor $1.6 million in compensation.Perth Now · 16 Nov, 20:01
- Court makes call on judge's contentious Facebook postsA court has made a ruling on claims by an ex-teacher, who appealed against paying a child sexual abuse survivor $1.6 million in compensation.The West Australian · 16 Nov, 20:01
In this story: Stephen Noga · Justice Stephen Estcourt · Grace Tame · Tasmania · Tasmania's Full Court of Appeal
This summary was written by AI from the headlines and standfirsts above, and states as fact only what at least two outlets report. How we use AI · Report a problem · Corrections log
Comments (0)