Kentucky Democrat wins magistrate race decided by coin toss
Summarised from 2 outlets · Updated 9 Nov, 05:54 · Archive
A Kentucky magistrate election ended in a 91-91 tie, decided by a coin toss under state law.
Democrat Kristen Fryman and Republican Benny Ray Renner tied with exactly 91 votes each in a Robertson County magistrate race in Kentucky. Under state law, election officials resolved the deadlock with a coin toss using a quarter borrowed from the sheriff. Renner, whose name appeared first on the ballot, called heads. The coin landed tails, making Fryman the winner of the 2nd District magistrate position on the county's fiscal court, which sets the local budget and tax rates.
Fryman told local public radio station WEKU that she had not expected to win in this manner. 'We laughed about it, and I left here as the winner and with the quarter in my pocket,' she said. She added that when she learned of the tie, she was surprised: 'When it was tied, I was like, "Wow".' Of the 182 votes cast in the contest, Fryman received exactly half.
Fryman's victory maintains a Democratic majority on the county's fiscal court. The win came on the same day as the midterm elections, in a county that voted heavily for Republican candidates elsewhere, with President Trump winning the county with approximately 80 per cent of the vote in 2024. This was not the first election decided by coin toss in Kentucky; earlier in 2026, a Union County Republican primary also ended in a tie resolved by flipping a silver dollar.

How it is being reported
- Kentucky election decided by coin toss after both candidates scored same number of votesA Kentucky election was decided by a coin toss after Democrat Kristen Fryman and Republican Benny Ray Renner each received exactly 91 votes.Daily Mail · 9 Nov, 05:40
- Dem wins coin toss to break election tie, then takes home the quarterIt was a vote for change. A Democrat won election to a local seat in Kentucky by coming out on top in a coin-toss tiebreaker – then joked she ended up 25 cents richer, reports said. Democrat Kristen Fryman and Republican Benny Ray Renner each notched 91 votes in Robertson County’s race for a magistrate...New York Post · 8 Nov, 20:37
In this story: Kristen Fryman · Benny Ray Renner · Robertson County · Kentucky · Union County
This summary was written by AI from the headlines and standfirsts above, and states as fact only what at least two outlets report. How we use AI · Report a problem · Corrections log
Comments (0)