Federal appeals court backs NCAA five-year eligibility rule
Summarised from 2 outlets · Updated 6 Nov, 22:27 · Archive
A federal appeals court reversed a lower-court decision allowing athletes who graduated high school in 2022 to gain a fifth year of eligibility.
The 10th Circuit Court of Appeals in Denver handed the NCAA a significant victory on Friday in the case Wisne vs. NCAA, reversing a lower-court decision that had granted a fifth year of eligibility to players who graduated high school in 2022. The July lower-court ruling had contradicted the NCAA's new rule that granted five years of eligibility only to athletes in subsequent classes, effectively making all class of 2022 players eligible and creating what the outlets describe as 'nationwide chaos'.
Teams had rushed to sign players who had previously been relegated to the sideline. When the appeals court put the ruling on hold in August, many of those players nonetheless found their way onto rosters through favourable rulings in state courts.
The NCAA's chief legal officer Scott Bearby said the decision was 'consistent with the approach taken by every federal court of appeals' in similar cases, and acknowledged the organisation's concern that retroactively changing eligibility rules 'can destabilise rosters and disrupt the settled expectations of student-athletes regarding roster spots and playing time'.
The decision does not resolve approximately 200 state court cases involving as many as 850 athletes, which continue to play out across the country.

How it is being reported
- Federal appeals court hands NCAA a victory in struggle for five-year eligibility ruleFederal judges handed the NCAA a significant victory in its struggle to implement a new five-year eligibility ruling, though the win does nothing to tamp down dozens of similar lawsuits playing out in state courts across the country.Clickorlando · 6 Nov, 22:04
- Federal appeals court hands NCAA a victory in struggle for five-year eligibility ruleFederal judges handed the NCAA a significant victory in its struggle to implement a new five-year eligibility ruling, though the win does nothing to tamp down dozens of similar lawsuits playing out in state courts across the country.News4Jax · 6 Nov, 22:04
In this story: NCAA · 10th Circuit Court of Appeals · Scott Bearby · Denver
This summary was written by AI from the headlines and standfirsts above, and states as fact only what at least two outlets report. How we use AI · Report a problem · Corrections log
Comments (0)