Judge refuses to dismiss original Alex Murdaugh murder charges
Summarised from 2 outlets · Updated 20 Nov, 22:32 · Archive
A South Carolina judge has refused to dismiss the murder indictments against Alex Murdaugh. Judge Debra McCaslin made the decision following a hearing in November, allowing the retrial to proceed as scheduled for April 2027.
Murdaugh's defence team argued that state investigator David Owen gave misleading testimony to the Colleton County Grand Jury about blood spatter found on Murdaugh's shirt and shell casings recovered from the crime scene. They claimed these inaccuracies warranted dismissal of the indictments. An expert's initial draft report did not identify blood spatter on the shirt, but after further discussions concluded the shirt contained over 100 spatter stains.
McCaslin found no evidence of intentional prosecutorial or investigative misconduct. She stated that even if the disputed testimony about blood spatter and ammunition were excluded, the remaining evidence would still establish probable cause. Prosecutors argued that Owen's testimony was consistent with investigative findings and expert opinions available at the time of the July 2022 grand jury proceedings, and that sufficient independent evidence supported the indictments.
McCaslin acknowledged discrepancies in blood identification testing but said they did not justify dismissing the case, noting that such forensic disagreements could be challenged during the trial itself.

How it is being reported
- Judge denies motion to dismiss Murdaugh’s indictments, Sumter County trial remains scheduledJudge Debra McCaslin denied Alex Murdaugh’s motion to dismiss his indictments following a Nov. 13 hearing.WISTV · 20 Nov, 22:11
- Judge: Original Alex Murdaugh murder indictments will not be dismissedThe original murder charges against Alex Murdaugh will not be dismissed, and the retrial will proceed.Live5News · 20 Nov, 21:25
In this story: Alex Murdaugh · Judge Debra McCaslin · David Owen · South Carolina · Colleton County
This summary was written by AI from the headlines and standfirsts above, and states as fact only what at least two outlets report. How we use AI · Report a problem · Corrections log
Comments (0)