Man City guilty of financial breaches over nine seasons
Summarised from 8 outlets · 24 reports · Updated 6 Oct, 20:25 · Archive
Manchester City have been found guilty of 114 breaches of Premier League financial rules spanning 2009 to 2018.
An independent commission has found Manchester City guilty of 114 of 115 charges of breaching Premier League financial rules over nine seasons from 2009 to 2018. The commission ruled that City arranged 'sham' commercial contracts and relied on 'sham agreements' to artificially inflate revenue and reduce costs by more than £830 million, using secret funding from the club's Abu Dhabi owners to circumvent the league's financial restrictions.
The nine-year period covered by the ruling predates the unprecedented 100-point Premier League season achieved by City. The commission's judgment, released on Tuesday, detailed how City systematically disguised payments from its owners through falsified sponsorship agreements and other concealment methods over the extended period.
Manchester City has denied all wrongdoing and insists that 'a comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence exists' to support its position. The club filed an appeal on Thursday against the independent commission's ruling. A hearing to discuss potential sanctions is set to take place before Christmas, with the outcome still uncertain.
The guilty verdict has prompted widespread calls for severe punishment from figures across football. Former Leeds United manager Jesse Marsch told the Guardian that City should be relegated from the top flight, claiming that 'everyone knew' about the club's wrongdoing. He also expressed scepticism about City's financial activities during his time managing in the Premier League, noting inconsistencies when the club reported making money in 2022 despite significant spending.
Former Liverpool player Jamie Carragher has argued that punishment should span three to five years rather than a single season, to force players to leave and diminish any benefit of a brief penalty. He contended that a points deduction or single-season relegation would be insufficient given the prolonged nature of the breaches.
Rival clubs have expressed limited sympathy, with insiders suggesting they do not expect City to remain in the Premier League next season. Concern has been raised about the damage to the league's image and integrity. Other clubs are reportedly preparing legal action, with lawyers tooling up to seek redress if City's unfair advantages in European competition deprived them of comparable rewards.
Meanwhile, City face uncertainty over player futures and morale. Erling Haaland asked to be substituted during Norway's international match, appearing to limp, raising concerns about a potential injury ahead of City's fixture against Liverpool at Anfield on Sunday. Psychology experts have warned that the drawn-out nature of the appeal process could have negative long-term effects on the squad.

How it is being reported
- Manchester City's punishment should last up to FIVE YEARS so they are forced to sell stars, says Jamie CarragherManchester City were blasted by the Premier League last month for making 'sham' agreements to manipulate their financial accounts to the tune of £900million over a nine-season period.Daily Mail Sport · 6 Oct, 09:29
- Jamie Carragher calls for Man City owners to be stripped of club and punished over FIVE yearsManchester City have been found guilty of 114 breaches of the Premier League's financial rules over a nine-year period and Jamie Carragher says a serious and sustained punishment is neededMirror Sport · 6 Oct, 09:27
- Man City charges LIVE: Punishment causes Premier League split as £300m 'catastrophe' loomsManchester City are still waiting to discover their punishment for being found guilty of breaching Premier League financial rules, though they have appealed the decisionMirror Sport · 6 Oct, 07:09
- The man staking his reputation - and £100m - on taking down Man City: Richard Masters has faced down mutiny, a pandemic and the Premier League owners club. Now insiders reveal how he'll fight the biggest scandal in British sportDaily Mail Sport has consulted a dozen sources who know Masters and have worked around him to better understand the highest-ranking individual on the side of the establishment.Daily Mail Sport · 6 Oct, 02:00
- Explained: What other PL clubs expect to happen after Man City rule breachesKaveh Solhekol explains how the other Premier League clubs are reacting to Manchester City's rule breaches ahead of the appeal processSky Sports · 5 Oct, 17:26
- Man City's rivals do not expect them to be in Premier League next seasonSympathy is in short supply at other clubs after an independent commission laid bare the scale of Manchester City's rule breaking across nine seasons in a devastating decision published last week.Sky Sports · 5 Oct, 15:41
- Man City's rivals do not expect them to be in Premier League next seasonSympathy is in short supply at other clubs after an independent commission laid bare the scale of Manchester City's rule breaking across nine seasons in a devastating decision published last week.Sky Sports Football · 5 Oct, 15:41
- Man City situation to get 'immeasurably worse' as player concerns raised ahead of LiverpoolEXCLUSIVE: Manchester City's players could be suffering heading into their clash with LiverpoolMirror Sport · 5 Oct, 14:49
- ‘Big opportunity’ – Man Utd urged to sign Man City star after Premier League guilty verdictManchester United manager Michael Carrick (Picture: Getty) Teddy Sheringham believes Manchester United could be presented with a ‘big opportunity’ following Manchester City ’s guilty verdict and should make an enquiry for Elliot Anderson . A hearing is set to take place to discuss Man City’s…Metro · 5 Oct, 12:22
- Man City face £300m black hole in financial ‘catastrophe’ as two punishments proposedMan City are waiting to discover potential punishments after being found guilty of breaches of financial rules - a verdict which they are appealingMirror Sport · 5 Oct, 12:03
- Man Utd urged to make Elliot Anderson transfer swoop amid Man City relegation threatManchester City could be relegated as part of their punishment after the club were found guilty of breaching 114 of the Premier League's financial rules, and their star players could fleeMirror Sport · 5 Oct, 11:33
- 'Embarrassed' Man City owners could sell club after being 'disgraced' by guilty verdictManchester City's owner Sheikh Mansour has been thrust under the spotlight after the club was found guilty of serious breaches of the Premier League's financial rulesMirror Sport · 5 Oct, 10:46
- Anger, denial, conspiracy theories: How fans cope when their club does wrong amid Man City scandalIt was confirmed last week that Manchester City have been found guilty of all financial charges brought against themIndependent Sport · 5 Oct, 10:14
- £800m in, £800m out - Why Man City scandal shines light on Man Utd financesManchester City's owners have been found guilty of injecting money into the club. At Manchester United, fans are frustrated at how much has been taken out.BBC News · 5 Oct, 09:08
- How relegation could cost Man City over £500mThe i Paper explores the potential impact of City being relegated to the Championship if the guilty verdict is upheld after appeal, with the help of a football finance expertThe i Paper · 5 Oct, 06:00
- Manchester City must be relegated, says Canada’s ex-Leeds managerJesse Marsch alleges Man City's financial wrongdoing was widely known in the Premier League, and relegation must follow.Al Jazeera · 5 Oct, 00:22
- Erling Haaland demands to be subbed in another blow for Manchester CityErling Haaland asks for substitution and was seen limping during the game (Picture: AFP) Manchester City appear to have suffered a major injury blow after Erling Haaland demanded to be subbed off during his Norway clash with Portugal . The Norwegian goalscorer signalled to the bench to be taken…Metro · 4 Oct, 22:45
- Erling Haaland goes off injured for Norway as Man City handed another blowManchester City have endured a miserable week after being found guilty of breaking Premier League financial rules - and now star striker Erling Haaland has picked up an injuryMirror Sport · 4 Oct, 21:36
- Former Premier League boss Jesse Marsch claims 'EVERYONE knew' about Man City's cheating - and calls for club to be relegated after guilty verdictMarsch has claimed Man City should be relegated from the top flight as a result of the verdict. Man City confirmed on Friday that they have lodged an appeal to overturn the decision.Daily Mail Sport · 4 Oct, 19:18
- Ex-Premier League manager claims 'everyone knew' Man City were cheatingManchester City's systematic breaking of the Premier League's financial rules has sent shockwaves through the football world, but Jesse Marsch says it was common knowledge in the gameMirror Sport · 4 Oct, 17:37
- £65m Man City signing hints at return to old club days after 114 charges verdictA player who signed for Manchester City for £65million in the summer has hinted that he would be keen on a move back to his former clubMirror Sport · 4 Oct, 17:18
- We must account for anger being felt as Man City case sends shockwaves through footballMan City face severe penalties after being found guilty by the Premier League (Credits: Harvey Todd/Every Second Media/S) Football is an angry place just now. Consider that the Premier League ’s ruling on Manchester City ’s financial activities covers nine seasons – a period ending in 2018 – and…Metro · 4 Oct, 13:23
- Man City charges LIVE: Premier League teams split on punishment as club's appeal dealt blowThe latest news on the Manchester City charges as the club launches an appeal on the guilty verdict on 114 of the 115 chargesMirror Sport · 4 Oct, 12:10
- Man City get Premier League expulsion update as 'two punishments proposed'Premier League expulsion is possible for Manchester City after an independent commission found them guilty of all charges related to serious breaches of the league's financial rulesMirror Sport · 4 Oct, 10:04
In this story: Manchester City · Premier League · Jesse Marsch · Jamie Carragher · Erling Haaland · Abu Dhabi · England · Liverpool
This summary was written by AI from the headlines and standfirsts above, and states as fact only what at least two outlets report. How we use AI · Report a problem · Corrections log
Comments (0)