Reform MS banned from Welsh Parliament over demographic change comments
Summarised from 3 outlets · 4 reports · Updated 12 Nov, 12:21 · Archive
Joe Martin, a Reform member of the Welsh Parliament, was banned from speaking after raising concerns about white British people becoming a minority.
Joe Martin, a Reform member of the Welsh Senedd representing Caerdydd Penarth, was banned from speaking in parliament after raising concerns about Britain's demographic change. In the chamber, he asked Heledd Fychan, the Welsh Minister for Culture and Sport, for a statement on the 'demographic replacement of white British people taking place in the UK'.
Martin said the scale of change had been 'breathtaking', citing mass immigration and differing birth rates. He stated that in 37 years, in 2063, white British people would be a minority in the country, adding that this change had already occurred in London, Birmingham, Leicester, Slough, Luton and Manchester. He argued that 'at every opportunity, the majority of the electorate have wanted less immigration so that their nation can be preserved'.
Following his remarks, the Welsh Minister asked the deputy presiding officer for a ruling on whether the question complied with Senedd conduct rules. Presiding Officer Huw Irranca-Davies later branded Martin's comments 'discriminatory' and 'offensive', and banned him from speaking until he apologises.
In response, Reform announced on Wednesday that it would boycott plenary sessions in the Welsh Parliament. Helen Jenner, leader of Reform in Wales, said the ban was an 'infringement on freedom of speech'. She stated: 'Quite frankly, nothing would have happened to Joe had he said these things out on the street, so why should he be silenced in the parliament here in Wales?' Reform is the largest opposition group to the Plaid Cymru-led government.
Nigel Farage, Reform's leader, criticised the decision to ban Martin. Martin wrote that he had asked his conscience what the most important thing he could say in Parliament that week, and it prompted him to discuss white Britons becoming a minority. He stated the topic was difficult to discuss but that 'if something is important and true, you should say it'.

How it is being reported
- Why has a Reform MS been banned from speaking in the Senedd?Joe Martin has been banned from speaking until he apologises for his comments, as Gareth Lewis explains.BBC Politics · 12 Nov, 09:05
- I'm a Reform politician in the Welsh Parliament. Why have I been banned from speaking about demographic change?Each of us has a conscience we can choose to listen to. On Monday morning, I asked mine what the most important thing I could say in Parliament this week was. Unfortunately, it prompted me to talk about White Britons becoming a minority in Great Britain. I say unfortunately because it is a very difficult topic to talk about. TRENDING Stories Videos Your Say I usually get very nervous when I must talk about controversial things in the Senedd (the Welsh Parliament) and I had a feeling it would generate hysteria from Plaid Cymru, which is the governing party of Wales. Nevertheless, if something…GB News · 12 Nov, 06:00
- Reform boycotts Welsh Parliament after member banned for claiming 'British white people are being replaced'Helen Jenner said the ban was an ‘infringement on freedom of speech’The Independent · 11 Nov, 17:16
- Nigel Farage slams Reform politician being banned for speaking about 'replacement of white Britons'Nigel Farage has hit out at the decision to ban a Reform member of the Senedd from speaking in the Welsh parliament after he raised concerns over the scale of Britain's demographic change. In the Senedd yesterday, Joe Martin asked Heledd Fychan, the Welsh Minister for Culture and Sport, whether she could give a statement on the "demographic replacement of white British people taking place in the UK". The MS for for Caerdydd Penarth continued: "Because the scale of change has been breathtaking. Mass immigration and differing birth rates mean that, in just 37 years' time, in 2063, we will be a…GB News · 11 Nov, 15:15
In this story: Joe Martin · Heledd Fychan · Huw Irranca-Davies · Helen Jenner · Nigel Farage · Reform · Welsh Parliament · Wales
This summary was written by AI from the headlines and standfirsts above, and states as fact only what at least two outlets report. How we use AI · Report a problem · Corrections log
Comments (0)