Prosecutors deny falsifying evidence in Alex Murdaugh case
Summarised from 2 outlets · 4 reports · Updated 10 Nov, 23:44 · Archive
South Carolina prosecutors deny Alex Murdaugh's claims they fabricated blood-spatter evidence related to his wife and son's deaths.
Alex Murdaugh's defence team claims prosecutors presented fabricated forensic evidence when obtaining his indictment for the murders of his wife and son. The defence argues that an expert testified to the grand jury that blood spatter from the victims was found on Murdaugh's shirt, despite a state laboratory finding no human blood on it eleven months earlier. The defence says prosecutors presented false testimony from SLED Senior Special Agent David Owen, the lead investigator, and wants the indictment dismissed so the case can be presented to a new grand jury.
Prosecutors deny the fabrication claims, calling them "simply incorrect". They say a 2021 test found possible blood and spatter on Murdaugh's white shirt, and an outside expert later identified more than 100 spatter stains. Prosecutors acknowledge that investigators initially missed a separate 2021 lab report finding no human blood in samples from the shirt. They argue this report was in a lab file given to the defence but not initially provided to prosecutors or the expert. After reviewing it, the expert maintained there was blood spatter, concluding an earlier treatment of the shirt could have caused a false negative.
Prosecutors stand by their decision that there is sufficient evidence to support probable cause and that the legal threshold for dismissal has not been met. Murdaugh's next court appearance is scheduled for November.
How it is being reported
- Murdaugh defense responds to state’s opposition to motion to dismiss indictmentsAlex Murdaugh’s defense team has responded to the state’s opposition to his request to dismiss the murder indictments against him.WISTV · 10 Nov, 17:52
- Murdaugh defense responds to state’s opposition to motion to dismiss indictmentsAlex Murdaugh’s defense team has responded to the state’s opposition to his request to dismiss the murder indictments against him.Live5News · 10 Nov, 17:16
- Prosecutors deny falsifying evidence in Alex Murdaugh case: ‘Simply Incorrect’Over a week ago, Murdaugh’s legal team filed a motion to dismiss the criminal charges against him related to the deaths of his wife and son.Live5News · 9 Nov, 20:44
- Prosecutors deny falsifying evidence in Alex Murdaugh case: ‘Simply Incorrect’Over a week ago, Murdaugh’s legal team filed a motion to dismiss the criminal charges against him related to the deaths of his wife and son.WISTV · 9 Nov, 20:44
In this story: Alex Murdaugh · SLED Senior Special Agent David Owen · South Carolina · Colleton County · Moselle
This summary was written by AI from the headlines and standfirsts above, and states as fact only what at least two outlets report. How we use AI · Report a problem · Corrections log
Comments (0)