Nurse loses discrimination case against nursing union
Summarised from 4 outlets · 5 reports · Updated 4 Nov, 19:58 · Archive
A tribunal has ruled that the Royal College of Nursing did not discriminate against nurse Sandie Peggie over her gender beliefs.
An employment tribunal in Dundee has ruled that the Royal College of Nursing (RCN) did not discriminate against nurse Sandie Peggie because of her gender beliefs. In a 37-page judgment issued on Monday, Employment Judge Melanie Sangster dismissed all three of Ms Peggie's direct discrimination complaints against the nursing union.
Ms Peggie, a Fife nurse, had accused the RCN of failing to adequately support her during a dispute with her employer NHS Fife. The dispute arose after she shared a changing room with transgender doctor Beth Upton at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy in December 2023. She claimed the RCN had failed to advise her properly when she first raised the issue with one of its officers and had refused her request for legal assistance in relation to her claims against NHS Fife.
The tribunal found that the union official who first dealt with her complaint did not understand her gender-critical beliefs to be anything more than disagreement about the use of changing facilities. Ms Peggie had also accused the union of failing to seek full assurances from NHS Fife in relation to its policies on single-sex spaces.
Following the ruling, a spokesman for Ms Peggie said the judgment raised concerns about trade union membership, questioning the value of union support if members must identify their own legal claims rather than relying on union officers and their legal teams.
Ms Peggie's legal representatives confirmed on Wednesday that she will appeal the decision. A formal notice of appeal is expected to reach the Employment Appeal Tribunal within the next week. This comes after a separate tribunal in December 2025 partially upheld Ms Peggie's harassment claim against NHS Fife, while rejecting her broader allegations of discrimination, indirect discrimination and victimisation.

How it is being reported
- NHS nurse at heart of trans changing room row appeals court ruling on gender discrimination caseNurse Sandie Peggie will challenge an employment tribunal decision that cleared her trade union of discriminating against her on the basis of her gender-critical views. Her legal representatives confirmed on Wednesday preparations for the appeal against the Royal College of Nursing (RCN) are already under way, with a formal notice expected to reach the Employment Appeal Tribunal within the next week. The original ruling, delivered on Monday in a 37-page judgment by Employment Judge Melanie Sangster, found all three of Ms Peggie's direct discrimination complaints against the nursing union…GB News · 4 Nov, 16:23
- Trans row nurse Sandie Peggie appeals tribunalNurse Sandie Peggie will appeal against a ruling by an employment tribunal that a nursing union did not discriminate against her because of her beliefs about gender, her legal team has said.Sky News · 4 Nov, 10:16
- Sandie Peggie loses discrimination claim against nursing union over trans medic rowA nurse at the centre of a trans medic tribunal was not discriminated against by her union because of her gender beliefs, a judge has ruled.Daily Mail · 2 Nov, 19:17
- Trans row nurse Sandie Peggie loses discrimination case against unionThe Royal College of Nursing (RCN) did not discriminate against one of its members because of her gender beliefs, a tribunal has ruled.Sky News · 2 Nov, 18:15
- RCN did not discriminate against Sandie Peggie, tribunal rulesThe Fife nurse had brought the legal case against the Royal College of Nursing over what she claimed was discrimination over her sex-realist beliefs.Evening Standard · 2 Nov, 17:21
In this story: Sandie Peggie · Royal College of Nursing · Beth Upton · NHS Fife · Victoria Hospital · Kirkcaldy
This summary was written by AI from the headlines and standfirsts above, and states as fact only what at least two outlets report. How we use AI · Report a problem · Corrections log
Comments (0)