news.today
Hello · Register today | LoginHello · My Account[—] [33]
US

NY high school football coach resigns after playoff forfeiture

Summarised from 2 outlets · 3 reports · Updated 19 Nov, 17:02 · Archive

Middletown High School head coach Tim Strenfel resigned after his undefeated team forfeited a playoff win for fielding an ineligible player for 53 seconds.

Tim Strenfel resigned as head coach of Middletown High School in New York after the team was forced to forfeit a Section IX Class AA semifinal victory due to an eligibility breach. The team had been undefeated with a 9-1 record before the incident. During Middletown's 48-15 win over Valley Central on 6 November, a kicker who had been recruited from the boys soccer team played for 53 seconds across eight plays. The player was eligible for regular-season games but did not meet the postseason requirement of appearing in three regular-season games under New York State Public High School Athletic Association guidelines.

Strenfel had sought and received approval from the school's athletic director before adding the player to the roster, according to assistant coach Isaac Cayetano. However, Strenfel was unaware of the eligibility rule despite serving as head coach for ten years. After the game, coaches from Newburgh Free Academy, Middletown's intended championship opponent, noticed the ineligible player and reported the incident to Valley Central officials, who notified Section IX. The league ruled Middletown had to forfeit the win. The school appealed to the State Supreme Court but withdrew its petition after learning the judge would not rule in their favour.

Assistant coach Isaac Cayetano subsequently resigned, telling News 12 that the experience "left an awful taste in my mouth". He publicly questioned the school administration's role in the mistake, stating that whilst coaches could be blamed, so could school officials and the athletic director who "are supposed to educate us". The Middletown City School District opened an investigation into the error.

NY high school football coach resigns after playoff forfeiture
Image: Daily Mail Sport

Comments (0)

How it is being reported

In this story: Tim Strenfel · Isaac Cayetano · Middletown High School · Valley Central · Newburgh Free Academy · Section IX · New York

This summary was written by AI from the headlines and standfirsts above, and states as fact only what at least two outlets report. How we use AI · Report a problem · Corrections log