news.today
Hello · Register today | LoginHello · My Account[—] [33]
UK

Contractual weaknesses cost £5m in failed vehicle testing deal

Summarised from 4 outlets · Updated 17 Nov, 07:58 · Archive

A weakly drafted contract for vehicle testing equipment awarded by Northern Ireland's Driver and Vehicle Agency in 2019 ultimately cost £5 million.

The Driver and Vehicle Agency awarded a contract for vehicle testing equipment in March 2019 that ultimately wasted £5 million, according to a report by Northern Ireland's Audit Office. The original contract was valued at £10.8 million, but it was never delivered successfully.

The contractor fell six weeks behind schedule within just six months of winning the contract. By February 2022, the DVA had issued two formal warnings for poor performance and moved to terminate the contract. However, the contractor won a High Court challenge when a judge ruled that the contract did not specify clear dates for implementation of key systems. The BBC has previously reported that the company involved was Worldwide Environmental Products Inc.

The protracted legal process meant the DVA could not quickly end the arrangement. The contract was eventually settled in April 2025 with a negotiated payment of £1.5 million to the contractor in respect of costs incurred. This termination payment was described as 'a significant fruitless expenditure'.

Beyond the settlement payment, the DVA spent a further £3.6 million on staff and other costs related to the contract over its lifetime. The total £5.1 million cost encompasses the £1.5 million settlement, the £3.6 million in DVA costs, and other procurement and management expenses.

Auditor General Dorinnia Carville said the weaknesses in the contractual arrangements made it difficult to bring the contract to a timely conclusion once serious problems emerged. She described it as 'a missed opportunity to improve much needed services, as well as a significant waste of public money'. The report has urged that lessons be learned across the public sector.

A replacement contract was awarded in March 2026, with delivery of the new testing solution expected in 2029.

Contractual weaknesses cost £5m in failed vehicle testing deal
Image: News Letter

Comments (0)

How it is being reported

In this story: Driver and Vehicle Agency · Northern Ireland Audit Office · Dorinnia Carville · Worldwide Environmental Products Inc · Northern Ireland

This summary was written by AI from the headlines and standfirsts above, and states as fact only what at least two outlets report. How we use AI · Report a problem · Corrections log