Care worker wins £30k after disciplinary for discussing bonus cut
Summarised from 2 outlets · 3 reports · Updated 18 Nov, 13:38 · Archive
A care worker has won £30,000 after an employment tribunal ruled her dismissal was unfair following a disciplinary warning for discussing Christmas bonus cuts with colleagues.
Donna Williams joined Copthorne Care Homes in August 2012 as a night-time care assistant based in Penzance, Cornwall. For over a decade, all staff received Christmas bonuses. When new ownership took over in 2022, the policy changed. The care home introduced a system of rewarding only staff assessed as going 'above and beyond', rather than giving all workers the festive bonus.
In January 2024, following Christmas 2023, Williams was invited to a disciplinary meeting with bosses Anna Billinger and Emma Boase after she had been 'discussing the Christmas bonus with colleagues'. She was given a formal warning for raising the topic. The Daily Mail reports she was later sacked over other allegations including 'badmouthing' a colleague and leaving a woman in a chair all night.
Williams took the care home to Bodmin Employment Tribunal in Cornwall. The tribunal found 'there was no evidence of an instruction not to discuss bonuses' and ruled that bosses did not genuinely believe she had committed misconduct. It determined her dismissal was unfair. Williams, who has difficulty with mobility due to arthritis, was awarded £29,628.

How it is being reported
- That's not in the Christmas spirit! Carer sacked for speaking to colleagues about their festive bonus being cut...but wins £30,000 for unfair dismissalDonna Williams was slapped with a formal warning because she asked other care home workers about changes to their festive bonuses, and for leaving a whole swede in a pan.Daily Mail · 18 Nov, 13:16
- Care worker who was given formal warning for asking about Christmas bonus wins £30kDonna Williams was given a warning for bringing the topic up and was later sacked over bogus allegationsThe Independent · 18 Nov, 12:21
- Care worker wins £30k after bosses gave her disciplinary for asking about Christmas bonusDonna Williams took her care home to Bodmin Employment Tribunal, CornwallThe Independent · 18 Nov, 09:32
In this story: Donna Williams · Copthorne Care Homes · Penzance · Cornwall · Bodmin Employment Tribunal
This summary was written by AI from the headlines and standfirsts above, and states as fact only what at least two outlets report. How we use AI · Report a problem · Corrections log
Comments (0)